The boy online was so cute. Pictured in the chat room profile was 17-year-old Dave Fagan, a long-haired surfer from San Diego, or so he said. Actually, he was a 47-year-old married father of two. David Fuller was also a predator; his chosen prey being a 12-year-old Arkansas girl.
Band, choir, school activities — the girl from Holland was good at lots of things, but she was the best at bringing the smiles. Kacie Woody was smart, too, excelling in advanced classes, though a bit precocious in a way fathers fear. Kacie wanted her very own boyfriend. Her dad, Rick, a Greenbrier police officer, knew she was online chatting with boys, but, hey, she was home safe and the boys online — well, they were out there somewhere. Better than wolves at the front door.

Kacie Woody
Yet there was a wolf at the door — or would be very soon. The child of upper middle class Mormon parents, Fuller had pushed back against their expectations, defiantly dropping out of school and spending his 20s playing guitar at one gig after another. In his early 30s, he enlisted in the U.S. Navy, and over time, the anger once masked by youthful partying began resurfacing. By 2002, the year this story unfolded, his wife was done. Their divorce came through at the end of the year.
His first arrest was for assaulting her — she was stunned that he had done that to her — and then there was a second arrest for exposing himself to two young girls. A report previously filed with California Child Protective Services had alleged Fuller was coercing his 7-year-old daughter into showering with him. In the child’s presence, he had adamantly denied it, but now his wife was certain a monster was emerging from her husband of almost 20 years.
Fuller’s employer cut ties with him, as well, after he was caught with porn at work. His appetite uncurbed, he pivoted in a way that would conceal his identity, and for the next several years, “Dave Fagan” trolled chat rooms created for teenagers. On Yahoo, in a Christian chat room, he found Kacie.
One sick ruse Fuller — aka Fagan — told Kacie was he had an aunt in Arkansas who was comatose due to a car wreck. It was a lie, but it served to create a special bond with the girl, whose own mother had died in a crash when she was 7. In a self-comforting sort of way, she told others her mama was an angel that she would someday join in heaven.
In mid-2002, Fuller said he turned 18, which, her father insisted, was too old for him to be messaging her. Kacie stopped the online chats, but with a wink, she and “Fagan” began calling instead. The predator continued to build trust with her by befriending some other kids online who were Kacie’s local friends.
For her part, Kacie had begun messaging Scott, a 14-year-old football player whose last name has been kept anonymous. On Oct. 3, Kacie jubilantly messaged they were officially a couple, describing him as “the sweetest, cutest, smartest, funniest, sexiest guy ever.” “Fagan” was chill, but Fuller then began to cross boundaries literally and figuratively. Barely a week later, on Friday, Oct. 11, Fuller flew into Little Rock.
On Saturday, Kacie was crowned seventh grade queen of Greenbrier Middle School’s Fall Festival. The following week, she blew out 13 candles on her birthday cake. Still in Arkansas, Fuller made no attempt to contact her, nor did “Fagan” indicate he was anywhere but California.
Fuller made a second flight to Little Rock in early November. In California, he had been shopping — a gun, zip ties, chain, duct tape and chloroform. This trip, he rented the largest unit at Conway’s Guardsmart Storage, telling the manager he bought and sold vehicles in the region and would need a storage area sometimes. The manager did not much buy this guy’s story and made real sure his credit card was good.

David Fuller
The first Tuesday in December started as a mean, cold day, but things got hot fast at school when Kacie’s close friend, Samantha Mann, saw Scott’s picture on her locker door. Yes, Kacie admitted, she gave him her address so he could mail it to her. Though Samantha persistently warned her about those online types, in Kacie’s mind, they all were just friends, local and online.
Exasperated, Samantha went to the counselor’s office, hoping maybe an adult could get through to her friend. Kacie was summoned to the office, where she fibbed, assuring the counselor her dad knew everything she did, and no, of course, she would never meet in person anyone she met online.
The dust-up between the girls was over and quickly forgotten. Toward the end of the school day, Kacie asked Samantha and then two other girls if she could spend the night. It was a school night, however, and they all said no. Kacie played off any concerns, ending the day with a hug for each of them. It was Dec. 3, 2002, the day she would meet with someone she had met online.
The missing child alert hit before dawn. Close to midnight, her brother came home to find her gone. Immediately released from duty, her father was quickly joined in the search by officers from multiple agencies.
It started at the Woodys’ house, the last one on an unpaved rural road. There was no sign of forced entry and no immediate evidence of a crime, but despite the below-freezing weather, her coat was still there. Her damaged glasses, tossed aside, spoke for her, as did the limp of her distraught Yorkie. Finally, there were two names on a crumpled piece of paper in a wastebasket. One was Scott’s. The other was Dave Fagan’s.
In an affluent suburb of Atlanta, Scott’s parents were shocked by the FBI’s request to establish their son’s identity, as well as his whereabouts the previous night. Their son had an online relationship with a missing girl, agents informed the stunned couple, and now that girl was the subject of a national manhunt.
Scott was not hiding. Concerned for Kacie’s safety, he had spent the night messaging and emailing her. As Kacie’s chat messages confirmed, she had suddenly dropped off while messaging him. Scott said she was on the phone comforting “Fagan,” who said he was in Arkansas, his family not expecting his aunt to survive the night.
Arkansas law enforcement dug in, one team locating a Buick Regal with California plates parked at Motel 6 in Conway. It did not belong to anyone named “Fagan” the manager said. David Fuller was the name. He was an older guy who had gotten really nasty because they were having trouble with their internet connection.
The guy had checked in the day before and reserved the room for a week. Authorities found his possessions in the room, but clearly, he had not spent the night. Now his credit card number became a bloodhound for officers, who traced it to the rental of a minivan and a storage unit — Unit 313 — big enough for any sized vehicle.
Cautiously approaching, officers heard the sound of a radio coming from within the unit. Had Fuller learned a massive effort was on to find Kacie? The unlocked door signaled he might now be inside. The first slight lift of the door drew fire, a single gunshot. When law enforcement made safe entry, they found themselves facing the front of the van, the engine still running.
Fuller was located at the rear of the vehicle, dead on the concrete floor by his own hand. That was the shot they had heard.
The officer who opened the back of the van, finding Kacie, would later say the scene replayed in his mind every night he put his own daughter to bed. Fuller had chained Kacie’s wrists and ankles to the four corners of the van’s floor. The predator had taken his prey, killing her when his depravity was over. Based on the amount of chloroform in her body, it is believed that from the time of her abduction to her death, she never regained consciousness. It was the only mercy Fuller showed the child.
In Fuller’s California apartment, the FBI found multiple names, pictures, phone numbers and addresses. They included local Arkansas kids, as well as girls across the country who also thought Fagan was just a cute boy online. One item made clear who his favorite was — a framed collage of photos of Kacie.
Among law enforcement nationwide, Kacie’s murder is credited with being the case that brought law enforcement’s attention to this new form of predator, the online variety. Much was learned from the case that has gone to saving others, but stranger danger remains as close as the computer screen.
Kacie just wanted a boyfriend of her very own, and even being in a Christian chat room for teens did not protect her. At this very moment, there are close to half a million predators online whose appetite drives them to find someone’s sweet child, who could very well become an angel instead of a girlfriend. Beware the boy online.
READ ALSO: Murder Mystery: The Benton County 3










